China Justice Observer

中司观察

EnglishArabicChinese (Simplified)DutchFrenchGermanHindiItalianJapaneseKoreanPortugueseRussianSpanishSwedishHebrewIndonesianVietnameseThaiTurkishMalay

Independence of China’s SOEs First Recognized in South African High Court

Mon, 04 Sep 2023
Categories: China Legal Trends

On 30 May 2022, the High Court of South Africa handed down its judgment in DHL Project & Chartering Ltd v MV “Shandong Hai Chang” (A10/2020) [2022] ZAKZDHC 24, in which it expressly held that the Chinese state-owned enterprise (SOE) in question, Company T, was independent, and not under direct or indirect control of the Shandong Provincial State-Owned Asset Supervision and Administration Commission (SASAC) (see DHL Project & Chartering Ltd v MV “Shandong Hai Chang” (A10/2020) [2022] ZAKZDHC 24).

The information for this article comes from the social media of Cyan Law Firm, a leading arbitration law firm in China.

On 30 July 2019, The Hong Kong Arbitral Tribunal rendered an arbitral award in an arbitration dispute between the plaintiff, DHL, and the Chinese company, T, arising out of a voyage charter dispute concerning the vessel ZTH (ZTH), awarding T compensation to the plaintiff in the amount of USD 1,325,460.97. The plaintiff sought to enforce the said arbitral award and applied for the arrest of the defendant Shandong HC vessel (HC) in Richards Bay, South Africa, on 19 Feb. 2020.

The plaintiff had to prove that the owner of the defendant HC, Shandong HY Company, and the owner of the ZTH, Company T, were controlled by SASAC when the plaintiff’s claim arose.

SASAC was the majority shareholder of Shandong Company A, which owned 100 percent of Shandong Company B, which in turn owned 100% of Shandong HY Company, the registered owner of the defendant.

SASAC was also the controlling shareholder of Shandong Company S, which in turn owned 100% of T.

The plaintiff bears the onus of proving that when its claim arose, the defendant was an associated vessel of ZTH owned by T. This involves proving that SASAC had the power, directly or indirectly, to control T in the sense of controlling its fate and future.

In China, SASAC, as a government department, holds shares in SOEs on behalf of the government.

The High Court of South Africa held that because SASAC had initiated a reform and established SOE holding companies, it could only control SOE holding companies and was not entitled to control the fate and future of subsidiaries under SOE holding companies.

The High Court of South Africa noted that the SASAC had delegated its capital contributor rights to S and emphasized acting “in accordance with the law”. It was S, rather than SASAC, that appointed and removed T’s personnel. SASAC could not abuse its control over S and manipulate S’s decision in relation to T.

 

 

Photo by Matze Bob on Unsplash

Contributors: CJO Staff Contributors Team

Save as PDF

You might also like

China Enacts Landmark Private Economy Promotion Law

China enacted its landmark first Private Economy Promotion Law, effective May 20, 2025, to guarantee fair competition, streamline market access via a unified negative list, and bolster private enterprises through financing, innovation, and service support.

China Strengthens Criminal IP Protection with New Rules

In April 2025, China’s top court and procuratorate jointly issued a new judicial interpretation to clarify standards for handling criminal intellectual property infringement cases, aiming to strengthen IP protection, particularly in the service sector.

SPC’s 2024 Typical IP Cases Include AI Face-Swap Ruling

In April 2025, China’s Supreme People’s Court released eight typical IP cases, highlighting judicial responses to emerging issues in AI, gaming, and biotech, including a landmark ruling on AI face-swapping copyright infringement.

China Eases Tax Refunds to Boost Inbound Tourist Spending

In 2025, China has lowered its departure tax refund threshold from 500 RMB to 200 RMB and doubled cash refund limits to 20,000 RMB while expanding eligible stores and streamlining processes, aiming to boost inbound tourism spending and promote Chinese products.

Chinese Courts Bolster Pregnant Workers' Rights Protection

In April 2025, China's Ministry of Human Resources and Supreme People's Court released typical labor dispute cases emphasizing stronger protection of pregnant employees' rights, including a case where unlawful job reassignment and salary reduction were ruled illegal.

China Revises Marriage Registration Regulation

China's revised marriage registration rules, effective May 2025, eliminate location restrictions, simplify procedures by removing hukou requirements, and align divorce processes with the Civil Code's cooling-off period.

China’s SPC Issues Foreign State Immunity Case Guidelines

In March 2025, China's Supreme People's Court (SPC) issued procedural guidelines for handling civil cases involving foreign state immunity, implementing the country's shift from absolute to restrictive immunity under the new Foreign State Immunity Law.