China Justice Observer

中司观察

EnglishArabicChinese (Simplified)DutchFrenchGermanHindiItalianJapaneseKoreanPortugueseRussianSpanishSwedishHebrewIndonesianVietnameseThaiTurkishMalay

SPC Awards Largest Compensation in Vanillin Trade Secret Case

Sat, 24 Apr 2021
Categories: China Legal Trends

On 26 Feb. 2021, the SPC rendered the judgment, (2020) Zui Gao Fa Zhi Min Zhong No. 1667, of the appeal case concerned with technical secrets infringement of Jiaxing Zhonghua Chemical Co., Ltd. et al. v. Wanglong Group Co., Ltd. et al., ordering Wanglong Group and other accused infringers to jointly compensate the technical secret rights holders in the amount of CNY 159,000,000.

This case witnesses the largest compensation that Chinese courts have ever awarded in trade secret infringement disputes.

Vanillin is a kind of spice widely used all over the world. In this case, the plaintiff, Jiaxing Zhonghua and Shanghai Xinchen New Technology Co., Ltd. (Shanghai Xinchen) jointly developed a new process for vanillin production, which was protected as a technical secret.

In 2010, Wanglong Group paid the defendant Fu Xianggen (a former employee of Jiaxing Zhonghua) to obtain the technical secret of Jiaxing Zhonghua, the vanillin production technology, and disclosed the vanillin production technology to Wanglong Technology Co., Ltd. (Wanglong Technology). Wanglong Technology hired Fu, and later disclosed the alleged technical secrets involved in the case to Xifushi Wanglong Spice (Ningbo) Co., Ltd. (Xifushi Wanglong) to produce vanillin. After Wanglong Group and Wanglong Technology illegally obtained the technical secret, the vanillin production technology, they have been continuously producing vanillin since June 2011.

As Wanglong Group and Wanglong Technology illegally obtained the technical secrets involved in the case, there was no substantial investment in research and development costs, and they were able to sell vanillin products at lower prices, which had a great impact on the international and domestic market share of Jiaxing Zhonghua.

In 2018, Jiaxing Zhonghua and Shanghai Xinchen filed a lawsuit with the Zhejiang High People’s Court, holding that the defendants such as Wanglong Group had infringed on their technical secrets, the vanillin production technology, and asked the court to order the said defendants to stop the infringement and make compensation of CNY 502 million.

The court of first instance held that Wanglong Group and other defendants had infringed some of the technical secrets involved in the case and ordered them to stop the infringement, make a compensation of CNY 3 million for economic losses and RMB 0.5 million for reasonable expenses.

Some defendants, in this case, refused to accept the first-instance judgment and appealed to the SPC.

The Intellectual Property Tribunal of the SPC found that the defendants such as Wanglong Group had infringed all the technical secrets involved in the case. On the ground of relevant data on economic losses provided by the right holder, after comprehensively considering the factors such as the severity of the infringement, the huge commercial value of the technology secret, and the fact that Wanglong Technology and other infringers refused to obey the binding behavior preservation ruling, the court of second instance rendered that the first-instance judgment shall be revoked and the above-mentioned infringers shall jointly and severally compensate the technical secret right holders CNY159 million (including reasonable expenses for rights protection in the amount of CNY 3.49 million). 

Contributors: CJO Staff Contributors Team

Save as PDF

You might also like

ABLI-HCCH webinar: Cross-Border Commercial Dispute Resolution – Electronic Service of Documents and Remote Taking of Evidence (July 10, 2025)

The Asian Business Law Institute (ABLI) and the Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH) will host their fourth joint webinar on July 10, 2024 (5:00–6:10 PM SGT), focusing on electronic service of documents and remote taking of evidence under the Service and Evidence Conventions, featuring expert speakers, with an early bird discount available until June 10.

China Tightens Corporate Personal Data Audit Rules

In February 2025, China's Cyberspace Administration issued the "Measures for the Administration of Personal Information Protection Compliance Audits", effective May 1, 2025, mandating regular audits for companies, especially those processing data of over 10 million individuals, to ensure transparency and legality in personal data handling.

SPC Releases Typical Cases on Telecom Fraud Crimes

In February 2025, China's Supreme People's Court (SPC) released eight typical telecom fraud cases, exposing new criminal methods and highlighting intensified judicial efforts after handling 31,000 such cases in 2023.

SPC Targets Cyber Extortion with Typical Cases

In February 2025, China’s Supreme People’s Court (SPC) released six typical cases showcasing its crackdown on emerging cyber extortion crimes, including spreading rumors and sextortion, to encourage victims to seek legal protection.

China Issues New Rules on Foreign-Related IP Disputes

In March 2025, China issued regulations effective May 1, 2025, to enhance dispute resolution, evidence collection, and countermeasures for foreign-related intellectual property disputes, strengthening services and enterprise capabilities.

SPC Issues China’s First Anti-Anti-Suit Injunction (AASI) in IP Case

In December 2024, China’s Supreme People’s Court (SPC) issued its first anti-anti-suit injunction in a patent dispute, Huawei v. Netgear, prohibiting Netgear from obstructing Huawei’s Chinese litigation, marking a significant step in global standard-essential patent governance.

SPC Launches Diversified Dispute Resolution Case Database

In February 2025, China's Supreme People's Court launched a public “Diversified Dispute Resolution Case Database” with over 200 cases, showcasing mediation and arbitration examples across various dispute types to guide alternative dispute resolution.