China Justice Observer

中司观察

EnglishArabicChinese (Simplified)DutchFrenchGermanHindiItalianJapaneseKoreanPortugueseRussianSpanishSwedishHebrewIndonesianVietnameseThaiTurkishMalay

China's First Case Over Facial Recognition Ruled in Hangzhou - China Legal News

Sat, 05 Dec 2020
Categories: China Legal Trends

avatar

 

On 20 Nov. 2020, the People’s Court of Fuyang District, Hangzhou handed down the first judgment over a facial recognition-related service contract dispute in Guo Bing v. Hangzhou Wildlife World Co., Ltd.. The court ordered the defendant Wildlife World to compensate the plaintiff Guo Bing for the loss of contract interests and the cost of transportation, totaling 1038 CNY, and to delete Guo Bing’s facial feature information including photos. Guo Bing’s request to confirm the invalidity of the relevant content in the Wildlife World store notice and SMS notification is rejected.

The plaintiff Guo Bing purchased the Hangzhou Wildlife World Annual Card and has agreed to enter the park by fingerprint recognition. Guo Bing submitted his name, ID number, phone number, fingerprints, and photos. Later, the Wildlife World adjusted the way for annual card customers to enter the park from fingerprint recognition to face recognition. The two parties failed to negotiate the way of entering the park, refunding the card, and other related matters, therefore, Guo Bing brought a lawsuit to the court for breach of the service contract.

The court held that the parties have entered a service contract relationship due to the purchase of the annual card for the park, and caused a dispute due to the change in the way of entering the park. The focus of the dispute was actually the assessment and regulation of handling of consumer personal information, especially personal biometric identification such as fingerprints and human faces.

Chinese law does not prohibit the collection and use of personal information in the consumer field, it emphasizes the supervision and management of personal information processing. That is, the collection of personal information shall follow the principle of “legality, legitimacy, and necessity”, and shall obtain the parties’ agreement. The business operators must ensure that personal information is used in a safe way, and the business operators shall not leak, sell, or illegally provide the personal information to others. When personal information is violated, the business operators shall bear the corresponding tort liability.

In this case, the Wildlife World changes the way of entering the park from fingerprint recognition to face recognition during the performance period of the contract, which is a unilateral change of the contract and shall be considered as a breach of contract. Guo Bing clearly disagrees with this change. Therefore, the relevant content of the store notice and SMS notification is not part of the contract between the parties, and thus has no legal effect on Guo Bing. Guo Bing, as the observant party, has the right to require Wildlife World to bear corresponding legal liabilities.

Contributors: Yanru Chen 陈彦茹

Save as PDF

Related laws on China Laws Portal

You might also like

China Eases Tax Refunds to Boost Inbound Tourist Spending

In 2025, China has lowered its departure tax refund threshold from 500 RMB to 200 RMB and doubled cash refund limits to 20,000 RMB while expanding eligible stores and streamlining processes, aiming to boost inbound tourism spending and promote Chinese products.

Chinese Courts Bolster Pregnant Workers' Rights Protection

In April 2025, China's Ministry of Human Resources and Supreme People's Court released typical labor dispute cases emphasizing stronger protection of pregnant employees' rights, including a case where unlawful job reassignment and salary reduction were ruled illegal.

China Revises Marriage Registration Regulation

China's revised marriage registration rules, effective May 2025, eliminate location restrictions, simplify procedures by removing hukou requirements, and align divorce processes with the Civil Code's cooling-off period.

China’s SPC Issues Foreign State Immunity Case Guidelines

In March 2025, China's Supreme People's Court (SPC) issued procedural guidelines for handling civil cases involving foreign state immunity, implementing the country's shift from absolute to restrictive immunity under the new Foreign State Immunity Law.

SPC Issues Prepaid Consumption Rules & Typical Cases

In March 2025, China’s Supreme People’s Court (SPC) issued a judicial interpretation and six guiding cases to tackle prepaid consumption disputes, invalidating unfair terms, protecting consumer refunds, and penalizing merchants who abscond with prepayments.

SPP Releases Guiding Cases on Civil Adjudication Supervision

In March 2025, China’s Supreme People’s Procuratorate (SPP) released new guiding cases to strengthen supervision over civil judgments, ensuring fairness and correcting errors in court rulings, covering disputes like private loans and traffic accidents.

First Tort Suit Under China’s Anti-Foreign Sanctions Law

In March 2025, China’s Supreme People’s Court (SPC) reported the first-ever tort suit under the Anti-Foreign Sanctions Law, enabling a Chinese firm to recover over CNY 84 million after a European partner withheld payment invoking a third country’s sanctions.

ABLI-HCCH webinar: Cross-Border Commercial Dispute Resolution – Electronic Service of Documents and Remote Taking of Evidence (July 10, 2025)

The Asian Business Law Institute (ABLI) and the Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH) will host their fourth joint webinar on July 10, 2024 (5:00–6:10 PM SGT), focusing on electronic service of documents and remote taking of evidence under the Service and Evidence Conventions, featuring expert speakers, with an early bird discount available until June 10.