China Justice Observer

中司观察

EnglishArabicChinese (Simplified)DutchFrenchGermanHindiItalianJapaneseKoreanPortugueseRussianSpanishSwedishHebrewIndonesianVietnameseThaiTurkishMalay

Shanghai Financial Court Enforces SIAC Award for the First Time

Tue, 11 Jan 2022
Categories: China Legal Trends

This case involved, for the first time, the situation where the arbitrator’s law firm was under sanction by China.

Can a foreign award be recognized and enforced in China if the arbitrator is a lawyer from a foreign law firm under sanction by China? So far, the answer is YES.

In December 2021, Shanghai Financial Court for the first time recognized and enforced a foreign arbitral award.

In this case, the Applicant, Bank M, was an offshore financial institution and the Respondent, Company W, was a domestic guarantor for a crude oil sale and purchase transaction between Bank M and the outsider H (Singapore) Ltd. Due to the default of the debtor H and the guarantor W, the Singapore International Arbitration Center (SIAC) awarded the guarantor to pay the corresponding amount. Bank M, as the creditor, applied to the Shanghai Financial Court for recognition and enforcement of the SIAC award.

It is worth noting that the Respondent Company W argued that this case shall fall into the circumstances under Article V of the New York Convention and thus the award shall not be recognized and enforced.

The Respondent proposed two arguments:

a). One of the arbitrators belongs to a law firm that is sanctioned by China and thus the award was unjust.

b). The Respondent is a Chinese enterprise engaged in the business of liquefied gas pipelines with a profound impact on society and people’s livelihood. It requests that the recognition and enforcement shall be denied under the “Rules on Counteracting Unjustified Extraterritorial Application of Foreign Legislation and Other Measures” (hereinafter “the Blocking Rules”, 阻断外国法律与措施不当域外适用办法).

So far, the only law firm that has been under sanctions by China is Essex Court Chambers in the UK.

Upon review, Shanghai Financial Court held that,

  1. With regard to the sanctions by China

The court held that the sanctions by the Chinese Foreign Ministry have targeted the law firm of the arbitrator in this case, rather than the arbitrator personally.

Moreover, the sanctions were imposed after the arbitral award was issued.

In addition, the sanctions were also beyond the scope of recognition rejection under Article V of the New York Convention and were not relevant to the case at hand.

In the process of selecting arbitrators, both the SIAC and the Applicant fulfilled their obligation to inform the Respondent and there was no undue process.

  1. The parties choose arbitration at their will, which is an act that does not involve the improper extraterritorial application of foreign legislation. Therefore, the Blocking Rules are not applicable in this case.

 

 

Cover Photo by Edward He on Unsplash

Contributors: CJO Staff Contributors Team

Save as PDF

Related laws on China Laws Portal

You might also like

CBIRC Relaxes Entry Terms of Foreign Insurance Brokers

In December 2021, China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission issued the “Notice on Clarifying Measures for the Opening-up of the Insurance Intermediary Market” (关于明确保险中介市场对外开放有关措施的通知) to relax conditions of market entry for foreign insurance intermediaries.

China Legalizes VIE Structure, Offshore Listings will Require Registration

In December 2021, China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) issued the “Regulatory Provisions of the State Council on the Offshore Securities Issuance and Listing of Domestic Companies (Draft for Public Comment)” (国务院关于境内企业境外发行证券和上市的管理规定(草案征求意见稿)), which for the first time clarifies the legality of VIE structure.

China Bans Unauthorized Short Videos about Films and Dramas

In December 2021, China Netcasting Services Association issued the “Guidelines for Review of Online Short Video Content (2021)” (网络短视频内容审核标准细则(2021)), which specifically prohibits contents edited or adapted from films, TV dramas, or online TV series without authorization.

China to Regulate Military Applications of Artificial Intelligence

In December 2021, China issued “Position Paper of the People’s Republic of China on Regulating Military Applications of Artificial Intelligence (AI)” (中国关于规范人工智能军事应用的立场文件) to strengthen the regulation of military applications of AI and prevent potential risks.